Psychologist vs Psychiatrist vs Psychotherapist

Differences Between Psychologist vs Psychiatrist vs Psychotherapist

Psychologist Vs Psychiatrist – Nowadays, it is not a luxury to take care of your mental health and seek the advice of professionals who can help you do so. With more people aware of the importance of seeking help, it’s now easier than ever to get the assistance you need. However, there are a plethora of approaches to having a productive conversation about one’s mental health.

Short Overview

Counseling, therapy, psychology, and psychiatry are just a few of the many medical specialties that focus on mental health. Despite the fact that they are all related and frequently used as synonyms, none of them are the same. Here we will understand the differences between a psychologist, psychiatrist, and psychotherapist.

Psychiatrists: The Medical Model, Diagnosis and Medication

Psychiatrists diagnose and treat a variety of mental health disorders. There are only a few mental health professionals who are qualified to prescribe medication because they have a medical degree and extensive training in psychiatry. In addition to providing psychotherapy, a psychiatrist, like a general practitioner, can conduct physical exams and order diagnostic tests.

Psychiatrists may collaborate with primary care physicians, social workers, occupational therapists, and psychiatric nurses in the treatment of mental health disorders.

To treat mental health conditions, psychiatrists typically prescribe medications, but they may also use a variety of psychotherapeutic approaches.

Mental disorders come in a wide variety of forms. For the most part, they fall into one of the following broad categories:

  • Anxiety disorders.
  • Eating disorders
  • Obsessive-compulsive disorders
  • Personality disorders
  • Mood disorders
  • Bipolar disorder
  • Specific learning disorders.

Psychiatry sits somewhere in between psychology (study of the human mind and behavior) and neurology (the study of the brain and nervous system). Psychiatrists typically look at symptoms of mental illness in one of two ways:

  • Determining the effects on behavior and mental health of a person of a disease, physical trauma, or substance abuse.
  • Examining symptoms in light of a person’s past or current condition (such as emotional trauma or abuse). 

One of the most important aspects of psychiatric evaluation is conducting a mental status examination (MSE). Attitude, behavior, cognition, judgment, mood, perception, and thought processes are all taken into account in this evaluation method of a person’s psychological functioning.

Psychological tests are used by psychiatrists to determine the presence and severity of specific symptoms, depending on the presumed condition being treated. However, it is up to a doctor to determine whether or not a patient’s symptoms are consistent with a mental disorder.

Examples include:

  • Anxiety tests: Liebowitz Social Anxiety Scale (LSAS) and Beck Anxiety Inventory (BAI).
  • Eating disorder tests: Minnesota Eating Behavior Survey (MEBS) and Eating Disorder Examination (EDE).
  • Depression tests: Beck Hopelessness Scale and Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HAM-D).
  • Mood disorder tests: Altman Self-Rating Mania Scale (ASRM) and My Mood Monitor Screen.
  • Psychosis tests: Scale for the Assessment of Positive Symptoms (SAPS) and Scale for the Assessment of Negative Symptoms (SANS).

Diagnosing mental illness often necessitates an exhaustive search for and exclusion of all other possible causes, similar to many other medical conditions. One of the most common diagnostic procedures is called a differential diagnosis, and it involves a combination of MSE and biomedical tests to distinguish between possible causes.

A psychiatrist may make use of the following types of biomedical tools:

  1. A physical examination.
  2. Electroencephalogram to pinpoint irregularities in the brain electrical activity, a head injury, a cerebral blood obstruction, or epilepsy. 
  3. Blood tests to determine blood chemistry, liver function, electrolytes, and kidney function that can directly or indirectly affect the proper function of the brain.
  4. Drug screening to notice illicit or pharmaceutical drugs in blood or urine sample.
  5. Brain imaging studies include magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and computed tomography (CT) scans.

    Treatment of mental disorders cannot be done without psychotherapy. It entails regular meetings with patients to discuss their problems, behaviors, feelings, thoughts, and relationships on a continuing basis. As a psychiatrist, your job is to help people find solutions to their problems by analyzing their thoughts and behaviors, as well as their past experiences and other internal and external influences.

    Individual, family, or group sessions with a psychiatrist are all options for those seeking psychotherapy. There are varying lengths of time psychotherapy can be used depending on the severity of the diagnosis and/or symptoms.

      Psychiatrists frequently use medications, each of which has a unique set of properties and effects. Any medication prescribed by a psychiatrist must have its mechanism of action and pharmacokinetics (the process by which a drug moves through the body) thoroughly understood by the psychiatrist. 

      • Antipsychotics are used to treat schizophrenia and other psychotic episodes.
      • Antidepressants are used to treat anxiety disorders, eating disorders, and personality disorders.
      • Anxiolytics are primarily used to treat anxiety disorders.
      • Stimulants are used to treat narcolepsy and ADHD (Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder)
      • Mood stabilizers are used to treat the schizoaffective disorder and bipolar disorder.

        Who is a Psychotherapist?

        Psychotherapists use talk therapy to treat mental health issues, such as anxiety and depression. There are many different types of psychotherapists, each with their own set of training and certifications. Individuals, groups, couples, and families can all benefit from their services.

        When you’re dealing with emotional distress, psychotherapists use talk therapy to help you cope. From mild stress and grief to more serious mental illnesses like depression and anxiety, they can help with just about any problem you can throw at them. Medication or a change in lifestyle may be used in conjunction with talk therapy. 

        Different Types of Psychologists

        A psychologist is an expert in psychology, which is the study of our thoughts, feelings, and actions. Psychologists aren’t just one type of person; they come in all shapes and sizes. Talk therapy isn’t the only specialization available in the field.

        Clinical psychologists and non-clinical psychologists are the two main types of psychologists. There are a wide variety of specialties that clinical psychologists can specialize in, and they work with clients to help them with their mental health issues.

        Non-clinical psychologists focus on applied psychology instead of clinical work. They also work with a wide range of demographics, backgrounds, and issues, as well. Clients often work with psychologists to practice skills that help them achieve their goals, which can be viewed as mental exercises in either case.

        Different Types of Psychologists

        Clinical Psychologist

        Typically, a doctorate in psychology is required before one can work as a clinical psychologist. Diagnostic and therapeutic psychotherapy are the primary responsibilities of clinical psychologists, who work one-on-one with patients.

        Hospitals, private practices, outpatient centers, and government agencies are all places where clinical psychologists can be found. States have different requirements for obtaining a license for these professionals. One to two years of professional experience under the supervision of an experienced clinical psychologist is required in most countries.

        Non Clinical Psychologist

        A non-clinical psychologist can be a mental health professional, such as a counselor, psychologist, or other licensed mental health professional. Psychotherapists and other professionals who provide talk therapy and other forms of psychotherapy are collectively referred to as "therapists." It is possible to perform assessments, make diagnoses, and administer treatment for mental health issues while in therapy with a professional.

        Nonclinical psychologists typically obtain a Ph.D. in philosophy, though there is some overlap. It usually takes six to seven years to finish this degree. There is a lot of emphasis on research in a Ph.D., but other areas such as psychological assessment techniques, theories of psychotherapy, and ethical considerations are also covered in depth.

        Different Types of Psychologists

        Psychologist vs. Psychiatrist:

        PsychologistPsychiatrist
        Focus on treating emotional and mental sufferingFocus on medication management
        Help people who have been traumatizedHave a basic foundation in medicine
        The primary focus is on determining the root cause of a problem and solving it using talk therapy.The main focus is on identifying and medically treating disorders
        Work with individuals and groupsWork with patients individually

        Even though their primary focus is on medical and pharmacological interventions, psychiatrists are also qualified medical doctors who can write prescriptions for medications in conjunction with psychotherapy.

        Despite the fact that many psychologists hold doctorate degrees, they are not medical doctors and therefore cannot prescribe medication for their patients’ conditions. Instead, they focus on providing psychotherapy, which may include cognitive and behavioral techniques.

        Psychiatrists and psychologists can be helpful in a variety of situations. Diagnoses and treatments are often done together, but this is not always the case.

        Prior to seeing a psychiatrist, make sure you have health insurance that will pay for medication and other treatment options the doctor may suggest. It’s common for psychologists to offer sliding scale therapy in many cases.

        Approach to Treatment

        Psychiatrists have the authority to diagnose and treat mental illness because they are licensed, medical professionals. Psychiatrists can work in a variety of settings, including a hospital, rehabilitation center, medical school, nursing home, or private practice.

        Psychologists cannot prescribe medicines. Patients are counseled and observed closely to determine what kinds of therapies and exercises are best suited for mild mental health issues. As with psychiatrists, they can be found in the same places, but they prefer to work in private practice.

        Is a Psychologist or Psychiatrist Better for depression?

        The severity of your condition and your personal treatment preferences for depression will all play a role in determining which type of mental health professional you should see.

        An experienced psychiatrist can help rule out other medical conditions and prescribe medication that is tailored to your individual needs if you are suffering from severe depression and anxiety.

        But a psychologist can help you work on issues on an ongoing basis and medication might not be necessary if you’re going through a difficult time and want to better understand your thoughts and behaviors.

        Patients who need regular therapy sessions, as well as medication management, may benefit from seeing a psychiatrist and a psychologist together.

        Make sure the doctor you choose has a lot of experience dealing with depression anxiety and a style that makes you feel comfortable. Try another psychiatrist or psychologist if things don’t go well with your current one.

        Is a Psychologist or Psychiatrist Better for depression

        How Do I Choose Between a Psychologist and a Psychiatrist?

        Before contacting a psychiatrist or a psychologist, you must first determine the nature of your mental health issues. Consult a psychologist if someone you care about is under a lot of stress and showing signs of anxiety or depression. They will undergo mental therapy sessions with psychologists in order to calm their anxious minds.

        People who are suffering from severe mental illness should seek out the help of a psychiatrist. A person’s mood, behavior, and disruptions in daily life due to mental health issues are all signs of this.

        Patients with mental health issues should see a psychiatrist to get an accurate diagnosis and the best treatment options. 

        Where to start?

        Whatever your mental health issue, we can help you find a psychiatrist or psychologist who can diagnose and treat it. A holistic approach to diagnosing and treating depression is taken at Soul Mechanics Therapy, Malaysia. We also offer affordable mental health care. Learn about our various treatment options for depression or schedule a consultation with one of our specialists. Contact us today.

        The Bottom Line

        Here are the main differences between psychiatrists and psychologists. We sincerely hope that this information helps you in your search for mental health care professional.

        When it comes to treating patients with mental illness, psychologists and psychiatric physicians are equally qualified. No one is better than the other; both are experts in their respective fields, and the best results can be achieved when they work together.

        Leave a Reply

        Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

        Thank you for all your love & support, dear clients.

        We are opening a new branch in Ipoh on Dec 4th!

        ×

        Soul Mechanics Support

        × How can I help you?